I went with none of these, I found some Procomp Xterrains all 5 for with wheels, So i sold the wheels on the Comps and my 2 tires that where good, and out the door I paid 650 remounted and balanced. I got them 18/32, new spare at 21/32 so I was extremely happy, then I got to use them at Jeepin for Jugs and they where amazing, dropped Air pressure from 35 to 25 and ran the whole day no problems no damage to the tires.